Posted by
Political Fan on Thursday, July 06, 2006 10:15:22 AM
E.J. Dionne, Jr, Op-ed columnist writer for the Washington Post, penned a piece titled A Dissidents Holiday, proclaiming the goodness of the never ending America bashing from the progressives. Dionne asks:
Have you ever noticed a certain hesitant quality to the expressions of patriotism by progressives or left-wingers? The patriotism of the conservative goes unquestioned But the progressive and the reformer have a problem with what passes for unadulterated patriotism. By nature, the reformer is bound to insist that the country, however glorious, is not a perfect place, that it is capable of doing wrong as well as right.
A certain hesitant quality? Were it only true. My experience is that finding true expressions of patriotism from hard core progressives is like a treasure hunt: You keep hearing that it exists, but you can never seem to find it. Consider the statements of people like Natalie Maines of the Dixie Chicks in the London Telegraph.
"The entire country may disagree with me, but I don't understand the necessity for patriotism," Maines resumes, through gritted teeth. "Why do you have to be a patriot? About what? This land is our land? Why? You can like where you live and like your life, but as for loving the whole country I don't see why people care about patriotism."
Well she is just a country singer, right? What about the feelings of National pride from a well-connected political activist who would certainly know more than a country singer? From the Daily Kos:
Today I walked out of church about a third of the way through the service. A soloist was performing "God Bless the USA." I have always found that song to be especially cloying, but when I noticed it listed in the bulletin I decided to attempt to tolerate it. And I might have managed to do just that had not one or two individuals prompted the entire congregation to stand.
At that moment I felt as though I'd been punched in the gut. And it was a double whammy - not only was I offended politically, I was deeply offended spiritually. I would never under any circumstance stand in tribute to a performance of that particular song. As far as I'm concerned asking me to stand in a sanctuary bordered on blasphemy. How could I in good conscience stand to embrace the lyrics "I'm proud to be an American" in the very same week we learned U.S. soldiers raped an Iraqi woman then murdered her and her family to cover up the crime? What spiritually unwise person planned this nonsense?
Kos, no doubt, is referring to the arrest and charges against Private Steven Green. The charges are horrible and, if true, he faces the death penalty. Kos, it seems, has already convicted Private Green of his charges as he does not have the presence of mind to assume innocence before guilt. But does the action of a lone private acting on his own undermine the sentiment that Im proud to be an American"? Does it undo the good the US did to defeat Naziism? Does it override the benefit of causing the collapse of the USSR? What about other acts of kindness from Americans such as the nearly billion dollars the Congress gave to tsunami victims or the hundreds of millions of dollars we give to fight malaria and AIDS? No? I thought not.
A certain hesitancy on the part of many liberals would be understandable, but why must their patriotic beliefs always be tied to what they believe America must eventually become and be so unwilling to be proud of all that we do which is good? We all have the freedom to believe as we wish, but it is clear to me that the never-ending critisism of the "progressive" will never pass for what we have known for 230 years as patriotism.